Here's an example: Consider a ball or block sliding down a frictionless ramp at the edge of a drop off. The goal is to calculate the horizontal distance it will fly before hitting the ground. Here's a quick sketch with the appropriate equations:

example problem with equations |

Doing the problem algebraically all the way before plugging in numbers lets students see what actually matters (in this case, the heights of the ramp and the drop off). Students can then easily answer questions like "what would happen if you double h?" or "What would happen if you doubled the mass while tripling the strength of gravity?". That last one causes groans for the students who've plugged their numbers in right away.

Another cool thing about this particular example is that the actual motion on different planets would be very different. On the moon the horizontal speed would be very slow but the fall time would be long, exactly canceling each other!

When I push this method with the teachers that I teach (trying to get their physics license while already having another science license), most come to like the way that follow up questions are more fun and straightforward. Some take a while to come around, though, as they like to grab their calculators right away. The phrase "would it be the same on another planet?" usually works to get them to at least recognize the importance of canceled terms.

P.S. You get the same result for a ball that rolls without slipping on the ramp. The horizontal speed decreases a little but mass still cancels (at least for spherically-symmetric balls) and the fall time stays the same. "g" still goes away at the end.

I didn't know about this blog which seems a good idea on several levels from meeting your goal to helping the rest of us think about mathematics and physics. I hope it grows.

ReplyDeleteI also liked your son's resolution and his answer. Ah, the locked diary is so kid-like and I can imagine the delight he has in having the key and access to it. It is the equivalent, I suppose, of having a pouch handcuffed to your wrist as you transport a top secret packet from one place to another.

You've described phyics as what's on top, what's on bottom and why. In that spirit I wonder if this could also be used as an assessment item in which you'd present the diagram and equations and ask students to explain it top to bottom mathematically and also the physics involved.

You could also ask the questions about the other planet and also the ball on a ramp that rolls without slippage as well as others you noted in the discussion of the algebra.

I ask this in the spirit of "there is no such thing as a dumb question" but suspect that in reality, there may just be such a thing. The question I pose might be too simple for your physics students even in a first course but at some level is a worthwhile question, assuming of course, the necessary modifications to make it a worthy question as well as clear one.

Keep pecking away.